Published October 12, 2026

Would You Rather Get $10K Off The Price… or $10K Toward Closing Costs?

Author Avatar

Written by Jay Day

Would You Rather Get $10K Off The Price… or $10K Toward Closing Costs? header image.
🎙️ NEW EPISODE: Real Talk Real Estate Podcast 🎙️

Would you rather get $10K off the price… or $10K toward closing costs? 🤔

They’re not the same deal, and picking the wrong one could cost you every month for years.

Andy and I get into what’s really happening right now with price cuts and seller concessions, nationally and here in Frederick County:

🔻 Why are so many Frederick listings quietly dropping their price?
💸 Lower price, closing help, or a rate buy-down: which one actually helps YOUR situation?
⚠️ The concession mistake buyers make when they don’t check their loan limits first
🏗️ Can a builder’s incentive rate make a new build cheaper per month than a resale?
🏠 Sellers: getting showings but no offers? Here’s how to find the sticking point before you cut
📊 So… is Frederick a buyer’s market yet? (The answer might surprise you.)

If you’re waiting on rates to drop, give this one a listen first. 🎧

 

🏡 HOUSE OF THE WEEK 🏡

A home with a second home built in. 👀

📍 13941 Green Mountain Dr, Maugansville, MD
💰 $475,000 | 5 Bed | 3 Bath | ~2,661 finished SqFt

The headliner is a private in-law/guest suite with its own separate entrance. It has a cathedral-ceiling living area, a full kitchen and dining space, a bedroom with French doors to the patio, and a renovated bath with a walk-in shower. Multigenerational living, long-stay guests, or space for a boomerang kid, it handles all of it.

The rest of the house earns its spot too:
✅ Fully remodeled kitchen with breakfast area and pantry, opening to a living room with cathedral ceilings
✅ Custom-milled hardwood floors on the main level
✅ Private primary suite with a soaking tub and two big closets
✅ Flex room for an office, playroom, or craft space
✅ Newer roof, siding, and windows (2021), two HVAC systems (2019), fresh paint and brand new carpet (2026)

Outside: mountain views from the front porch, a fenced backyard, a covered 11x16 deck, a paver patio, a French drain, and three storage sheds.

Updated, flexible, and move-in ready. Homes with a true separate-entrance suite don’t come up often. 🔑

Want the full tour? Comment “SUITE” or message us and we’ll get you in.

Jay Day And The Day Home Team at LPT Realty
📞 866-702-9038

#JayDayAndTheDayHomeTeam #DayHomeTeam #LPTRealty #RealTalkRealEstatePodcast #MaugansvilleMD #HagerstownMD #WashingtonCountyMD #FrederickMD #HouseOfTheWeek #MultigenerationalLiving #MarylandRealEstate

Full episode transcript

Andy: I'm Andy Webb.

Jay: And I'm Jay Day.

Andy: And this is Real Talk Real Estate. Jay, I was chatting with Christina last week, and we talked about interest rates going up. Do you buy? Do you freeze? What do you do? With interest rates, it's a whole big dance, as we talked about. And now, with interest rates the way they are, it's making people take a second look at what they're pricing their home at, right? Do we cut the price? Do we hold firm? What do we do?

Jay: Yeah. And it's interesting, because as I was thinking about what we were going to talk about today, I was like, let's talk about the reality of what we're seeing in the current market, and that deals with price cuts and concessions. When we look nationally, one in five sellers just cut their price. So if you're shopping right now, that could be a great thing, because you have the potential of getting a home for a little bit less money. And again, that's one in five nationally. I will tell you that when I looked at the numbers for what's actually active right now in Frederick County, leaving out new construction, 49% of all homes listed as active for sale have had a price reduction.

Andy: Wow.

Jay: So it's no longer one in five. It's a much bigger number for those here in Frederick that are currently active on the market. It's basically one in two.

Andy: It's almost half.

Jay: Yeah. So big, big opportunity, because guess what wasn't happening when the market was hot? There were no price drops. It just didn't happen. So we're going to give some national numbers and some local Frederick County numbers here. Just under 21% of active listings had a price cut in September nationally. That's the highest share Realtor.com has seen in any September going back in time. In Frederick, of the units sold in September, 33.6% actually had a price cut. So of the homes that actually settled in Frederick County, pretty much a third of them had a price reduction. Again, still better odds than one in five, right?

Andy: Right, absolutely.

Jay: Then we look nationally at the median list price, and this is really interesting, because it falls into what you and Christina talked about last week. Nationally, the median list price is down 1.4% from a year ago. That's the 11th straight month of declines nationally. In Frederick County, when we look at what sold in September, prices were up 6.5%.

Andy: Wow.

Jay: So what is that telling you? Even though interest rates have climbed, sales prices are climbing too, and they've climbed 6.5%. So by waiting for the rates to drop, you're not helping yourself, because prices are still increasing. And once interest rates drop, you're going to have more demand and more competition. Now is a good time to get out there, because you can get price reductions and maybe seller concessions right now. Again, waiting has not helped anybody in the Frederick County area.

Andy: Certainly not recently, if we're looking at that type of increase.

Jay: So then we looked nationally. Sellers gave concessions in 44.7% of sales in August, the highest August share in records going back to 2020. So again, big, big numbers.

Andy: What are concessions?

Jay: Concessions could be a multitude of things: closing help, rate buy-downs, repairs, or just the seller paying some of the closing fees. In Maryland, the closing fees are pretty big compared to what you have to pay to close in other states. Now, 15.2% of Northeast listings had price cuts versus 22.8% in the West. So the East Coast is seeing fewer price cuts than the West. However, like we said, in Frederick County we're looking at 49%, just under 50%.

Andy: One of the few ways we want to be like the West Coast. We like those prices going up, so people feel like they're getting their money's worth.

Jay: Yeah. So if you're a buyer, what does this mean? Where's your leverage? Price cuts versus concessions. A lower price lowers your loan. However, closing cost help can buy down your rate, or it can reduce how much money you need to bring to the table. So when you're trying to figure out what makes more sense, do I want to buy the house for less money, or would I rather have concessions? If you get the house for less money, you're financing off of a lower price. However, if you get concessions, you can use them to either bring less cash to the table or talk to the lender about buying down the interest rate. So a couple of options. If cash is tight, the lower price may not solve that problem. So decide whether you want to save now or save later. If you look at homes that sat for a while or already had a price cut, there could be a combination. Let's say you see a house that's been on the market for 70 days, and they had a $20,000 price cut 45 days ago. That's one where you may be able to also get concessions. So you got a discount, and you could also potentially bring less money to the table or, like we talked about, buy down the rate. Another thing in the market we're in right now: keep your inspections. We talked about how, in the hot market, people were waiving inspections. Now you have the opportunity to do the inspections, and we're also seeing credits come up to offset repair costs. I was working on comps in Pennsylvania the other day, and there was a home that sold for 200-some thousand with a $20,000 concession to do repairs to the house.

Andy: That's a huge percentage for that sales price.

Jay: So that's important to know. And the most important thing is, depending on the type of loan you have, there's a cap on the amount of concessions that will be allowed. So you want to make sure your real estate agent and your lender are involved, because you don't want to ask for 6% in concessions when you're capped at 3%. That's 3% you're losing.

Andy: Right.

Jay: So you definitely need to take that to your lender and your agent to make sure you're asking for the right number. Now, sellers, the question you have is, why are our houses sitting? Why are homes not moving? If you priced the home at last spring's numbers, that's not working as well anymore. Here, again, we're still seeing increases. But what we're seeing more is, if you saw something sell last spring, you're trying to add 10% or something higher than what is really happening. So if you're getting showings but you're not getting any offers, you've got to figure out what the sticking point is. Is it price, payment, condition? Figure that out before you make any changes. You need to know what is causing the issue. And concessions can protect your sales price instead of a price drop. We talked about that. What we're finding now is that in the builder world, you're getting a really good opportunity to get some great deals on new construction. The reason is a lot of these builders have lending companies, or tie-ins with lending companies, and they buy money at a lower rate. So we're seeing some builders offering five and a half percent interest rates. So when you look at it, if you're a resale and your house is listed for, let's say, $450,000, and new construction is $475,000 for a townhouse, but the interest rate on your house is seven and a half and the builder's is five and a half, you're losing on payment, right? Those payments are going to be really, really close. Sometimes we're seeing new construction beat what the payment would be on a resale home. And the advantage of new construction is you've got a brand-new roof, new HVAC, warranties, things of that nature. So you really want to be looking at all options. And Realtor.com has a watch list for October. They're trying to see whether more sellers are starting to pull their homes off the market, or whether they're starting to make more concessions. What is that going to look like? I'm hoping we'll see reports on that from Realtor.com probably into November.

Andy: So, is it a buyer's market in Frederick?

Jay: Not really. It's not a buyer's market. And again, here's where we get into the definition. It's interesting, because people got so used to things selling quickly. But traditionally, one to three months of inventory is still a seller's market. Three to six months is considered stable. Once you get to six months and higher, it's a buyer's market. Right now, we're at about two and a half months of inventory. So we're pushing out of the seller's market into a stable market.

Andy: Not a buyer's market.

Jay: Again, short memories. A lot of people forget that it wasn't unusual for a home to take a couple of months to sell.

Andy: Sure.

Jay: We just need to have a little bit of patience. So the question is, if you're a buyer, do you want $10,000 off the price, or do you want $10,000 toward closing cost help? That comes down to what difference it makes in your payment if you take it off the price, or whether you'd rather have $10,000 extra in the bank because you got that closing help. What I would say is, if all of this is a little overwhelming, that's why you need a professional in your corner. You can always reach out to our team. You can go to our website, dayhometeam.com, or reach out to us at 866-702-9038. Again, 866-702-9038. We're here to answer questions. There's no pressure. If you're thinking about selling or buying but you don't know what to do, please reach out to us. We'll schedule a consultation and talk through all of the options. And if it doesn't make sense for you to do something right now, there's no pressure at all.

Andy: Right. I can vouch for it, because I'm doing this right now. I'm calling you or texting you about once a week.

Jay: Yeah. And you're not even selling with us; the home you're selling is in another state.

Andy: Right. But I come to you because you know what you're talking about and I need that expertise.

Jay: Right. And I always say, you've got to do what's right for you. Here's my suggestion. And when you're ready, and there's no pressure, we'll get out there, pound the pavement and find something for you here.

Andy: And it feels so good knowing that that's there. So I can vouch for that. Give them a call. They're great to have in your corner. And who knows, you may end up wanting this week's House of the Week.

Jay: Yeah. All right, let's talk about that House of the Week: 13941 Green Mountain Drive in Maugansville. This week's house has two homes in one, with a separate entrance and its own kitchen. This one is $475,000, with five bedrooms, three full bathrooms, and approximately 2,661 finished square feet on a 0.23-acre lot. It was built in 1998 and was a former model home. The highlight is the private in-law or guest suite. It has its own separate entrance, so it's not just the bedroom down the hall. It offers a cathedral ceiling, a full kitchen, a dining area, a bright bedroom with French doors to the patio, and a renovated full bath with a walk-in shower. Multigenerational living is one of the biggest trends we're seeing; we talked about that a couple of weeks ago. The kitchen was fully remodeled in 2019 with a breakfast area, pantry, new cabinets, countertops and appliances. There's the open living area with the cathedral ceilings we talked about, and custom-milled hardwood floors. The kitchen opens straight to a covered 11-by-16 deck, which works great for grilling or smoking with your Traeger. There's a large mudroom, a laundry room with backyard access, and a flex room that can be an office, playroom or craft room. The roof, siding and windows were replaced in 2021. Two HVAC systems were installed in 2019. Electrical and plumbing were updated in 2020. Bathrooms were remodeled in 2019 and 2026. Fresh paint and brand-new carpet in 2026. So we're talking about the big-ticket items and also some of the cosmetic things, all recently done for you. There are mountain views from the front porch, a fenced backyard, a covered deck with a new paver patio, extensive hardscaping, stone retaining walls, and a water fountain. A little bit of everything. If you go to wfre.com, check out the House of the Week. If you like what you see, click on the button to schedule a private tour. You're going to love it. It's a really, really cool house if you have a family member that needs to live with you, or, let's say you have young kids and a live-in nanny.

Andy: Right.

Jay: Yeah, it works out perfectly for that. Great house, $475,000, all updated. Check it out today.

Andy: Absolutely. I'm going to send them your way. I'm Andy Webb.

Jay: And I'm Jay Day.

Andy: This has been Real Talk Real Estate.

Categories

House Of The Week
Agent profile image in chat bubble
Agent profile image in chat header

Jay Day

Owner and Founder / Team Leader / Salesperson - MD, PA, VA & WV | Jay Day And The Day Home Team at LPT Realty

Agent profile image in message

or another way